Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Focal Calculator II
Lumenlab > Texts, Tools and Techniques > Calibration and Tools
Pages: 1, 2
kalari
Anyone using Vista might need to download a copy of Msvbvm50.dll to use this. There are a few places it can be downloaded from or get it from someone with XP. Placing it in the same folder with the FocalCalc exe should work.
giddavr
QUOTE (DAZZZLA @ Sep 19 2005, 07:42 PM) *
This calculator can be used to estimate various combinations of components in a projector.
The units can be changed by clicking on them. (mm, M, inches and Feet)
To find a certain value click on the checkbox next to the textbox and it will turn green. By changing one of the other textboxes the green selected textbox will display the result. For example if you have a 15” LCD and a 320mm FL triplet and you want to get a 100” screen then click the screen distance checkbox to turn it green then change the screen size to 100”. The green screen distance textbox will give you the required distance that the triplet will need to be from the screen. Or you might want to see how much bigger a 17” LCD would make the screen than a 15” LCD at the same distance. Select the screen size checkbox and then change the LCD size from 15” to 17”.

The FL of the triplet as a rule of thumb can be considered at the centre of the lens but this is not always the case. It all depends on the various elements in the triplet; it could be closer to the rear or closer to the front of the lens.

The value that is entered in the LCD size textbox will be the same type as the screen size textbox or vis versa. For example if you enter the LCD diagonal the result in the screen size textbox will also be diagonal. If you enter the LCD width then the screen textbox will also be width.

Warnings and messages:
If you enter a value in a textbox that can’t be used by the calculator then all other textboxes will turn red to indicate that a result is not possible. For example a zero value will cause an error. A message will pop up in the bottom right corner to indicate other types of errors. If in split then entering a value into the triplet FL that is less then the gap will cause an error because the triplet can’t be moved any closer than the physical position of the front fresnel.
You will probably notice that the labels above each textbox may sometimes turn red; this is just a warning that the value in that particular textbox is larger than what is being displayed. Use the arrow keys if you want to see the entire value.

Let me know if you find any bugs.
Please enjoy.

DJ

Bugs:
If you get a “Runtime Error ‘13’ Type Mismatch” message you will need to go into Regional And Language options in XP and choose English


Hi

I am unable to download the calculator. Getting a files moved error message.

gvr
Quasi_Mojo
QUOTE (giddavr @ Nov 17 2007, 11:16 PM) *
Hi

I am unable to download the calculator. Getting a files moved error message.

gvr

Try it again.
It just worked for me.
brick
QUOTE (DAZZZLA @ Oct 25 2007, 07:13 AM) *
The LCD distance will never be the same as the triplet’s FL. Read this to understand it a bit better.
The fresnel’s FL on the other hand isn’t matched very well and this will happen with almost all the DIY projectors you’ll see here. With the distances you have used, the correct fresnel FL should really be about 360mm (LCD distance - fresnel gap). It can be fudged though by moving the lamp closer to the rear fresnel so the light will refracted further forward so it can pass through the triplet. This isn’t the best approach but we have to use what we have on hand.

DJ

What about increasing the Fresnel Gap from 20mm to whatever allows the fresnel's FL to be close enough to the triplet? For instance, instead of 20mm, let it be 60mm or 80mm from the panel? I can't find much on the forums regarding the fresnel gap. Does it degrade image quality when it gets much farther than 20mm?

Obviously this would change the size of the projected screen, but if that wasn't an issue, would changing the fresnel gap work?

Thanks,
brick
Quasi_Mojo
Well... the DIY Projector Guide v2.0 says:

QUOTE
Our projection lens may have a focal length of 320mm, but the if the lens were only placed at its focal length from the LCD panel we would be focused on infinity, so in practical usage we would place it around ~340mm from the LCD panel as represented by line Z (note this distance will vary with different screen sizes). We leave a gap of ~15mm between the condenser fresnel lens and the LCD panel and a gap of ~20mm between the collector fresnel and the LCD panel. This is desirable because if a fresnel lens is too close to the panel, the grooves on the fresnel lens will be projected too. The larger gap for the collector fresnel is to give some room for keystone tilting if needed. If you have circular lines or Moire patterns in your projection your fresnels are too close to the panel.

http://www.lumenlab.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=8972

While it doesn't mention any maximum distance, I would guess that this might increase the size of the box. But I could be wrong.
DAZZZLA
QUOTE (brick @ Dec 8 2007, 09:25 AM) *
What about increasing the Fresnel Gap from 20mm to whatever allows the fresnel's FL to be close enough to the triplet? For instance, instead of 20mm, let it be 60mm or 80mm from the panel? I can't find much on the forums regarding the fresnel gap. Does it degrade image quality when it gets much farther than 20mm?

Obviously this would change the size of the projected screen, but if that wasn't an issue, would changing the fresnel gap work?

Thanks,
brick

You could increase the fresnel gap. Keep in mind though that it will degrade the image a bit more. 40mm doesn’t seem too much. It all depends on what is acceptable to you.

DJ
uptuse
Hey guys, got two questions.

1. The distance between the front Fresnel and the triplet -- how do i determine it?

using the Calc it is this --

Click to view attachment

However, shouldn't it be 342 since my triplet is 342 mm?

2. For a 15" lcd, the distance between the 220 mm fresnel and the LCD is 5/8 in, and 13/16 in between the LCD and front fresnel. Does this change when the LCD size changes?
teamwindsor
You find the distance between the front frensel and the triplet simply by using the distance focal calc gives from lcd to trip and simply taking roughly 20mm off. The program works by giving you the distance to focus on an image at the triplet, and this tends to be more than the focal lenght of the lens. With this value, the front frensel is then placed 20mm further on.

The distances between screen and frensel does not change with screen size, they are just estimates and you yourself will have to experiment to see what works best for yourself. generally from the lcd the rear frensel is 15mm away on the light side and the front frensel 20mm away on the triplet side. the front frensel being slightly further away allows better keystoning. if you find you are getting circles on your projection the frensel is too close and to solve this problem simply move it a bit further away....its all about incorporating the ability to tweak everything. wink.gif
Edwardswolentoe
Sorry to ask, but what relevance is image magnification. I say this as say you increase the screen distance, the projected screen gets bigger and the magnification increases. However when you increase the screen distance you get the projector out of focus and blurry.

Does this mean you want image magnification to be as low as possible? (Im assuming high values that give ridiculously large screens will be blurry)

Or what is the optimum image magnification that i should be striving for (Just a regular 15" lcd projector).

Also say the screen size is 2m, is that 2 by 2, or 2 meters diagonally (1 by 1)
Dan Kegel
QUOTE (computercowboy @ Nov 12 2006, 09:33 PM) *
if you run this on windows server 2003 or windows vista / longhorn

you will need to place msvbvm50.dll in your window/system32 directory


Same with Wine. If you're running Wine (say, on Linux or MacOSX) you
have to install the visual basic 5 runtime before running focal calculator.
Easiest way on wine is to do

CODE
wget http://kegel.com/wine/winetricks
sh winetricks vb5run


The calc works great the.
mdmfootball
QUOTE
Anyone using Vista might need to download a copy of Msvbvm50.dll to use this. There are a few places it can be downloaded from or get it from someone with XP. Placing it in the same folder with the FocalCalc exe should work.


That works perfect on vista (aka the worst thing ever created) by the way
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.