QUOTE (pitman2 @ May 21 2005, 08:11 PM)
Yeah, ALMOST all of the dvd's that are in 'THX' have the optimizer. But I think that I read somewhere that each of those optimizers are calibrated to the specific movie that they're on. I'm not sure though so don't quote me on that.
That's correct - the THX optimizer will be slightly different for each movie. That doesn't necessariliy make it a bad choice for adjusting the picture.
The best THX optimizer I've found that has good results across the board for me has been the Incredibles (there's even an advanced optimizer that's not available anywhere else). I've used this in combination with a good live-action film to achieve solid results. I picked several varied scenes from Garden State and played them after making changes on the Incredibles DVD.
I've tried the Star Wars optimizers and find they wash out the image a bit more than I'd like.
I've yet to try the Pirates of the Carribean one, but I'd bet it would be interesting to see what would happen there, considering the overdone contrast in that film.