Works regardless. Vertical is not an option since the bulb is too long to fit in the box, and really it depends on what is more useful to ME on whether vertical or horizontal shift is preferred.

The bulb came with the ballast, which can also drive MH bulbs, so if I feel like redesigning the light engine I have the option. I am well aware of the attitudes about HPS on this forum and diyAudio.
I obeyed few of the rules here, I used a laptop and screen, I used HPS light source, I used a 330mm for light collection and paired a 500mm with a 355mm triplet and I made it vastly more complicated with electronic lens shifting and folded design, but somehow it works...
So my experience is:
1. A laptop works for me and really was easy with just the custom FPC to build. I could have done without the FPC if I did a straight through design, but the placement of the mirror eliminated that option.
2. For kicks I tried a 330mm fres with the triplet (for a close match) and as I had guessed it just didn't work. 500mm is perfect.
3. If I decide I need a longer throw with a smaller picture I can change to the 18" bessler with only an adjustment of the mirror/focusing sled required. An awkward zoom solution, but effective.
I will continue to update the progress and eventually figure out my camera settings for good screenshots.