Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: M. Night Shyamalan - What happened to him?
Lumenlab > Community Interests > General Discussion
Quasi_Mojo
M. Night Shyamalan - What happened to him???

I really enjoyed "The Sixth Sense"! "Signs" was stupendous! I even thoroughly enjoyed "Unbreakable".

I just watched "The Happening" tonight. Thankfully, I didn't have to pay to see it. I'm not against paying to see good movies - I own over 750 retail DVDs.

I was looking for something online - some critic from a reputable source who might have penned the words to help me describe the feelings I had after watching this movie. In my opinion, he's been on a downhill ride to the end of his career ever since "The Village" came out.

I found the following review, which I started to like... but I wasn't sharing the optimism that the writer was expressing towards the end of the piece.

QUOTE
Posted by Sean Stangland on Sat, 06/14/2008 - 12:49

The reviews are in, and there seems to be a national consensus: Film critics and Internet geeks have decided that M. Night Shyamalan's career is over.

With the notable local exceptions of our man Dann and Roger Ebert, the film geeks just loathe "The Happening," Shyamalan's new throwback to '50s B-movies where the horror on the screen is delivered with a heavy-handed message about the horrors in real life. In the '50s, it was nuclear power and Communism; in "The Happening," it's global warming and pollution.

I think the film was clearly intended on that level, and works as a fun homage to those B-movies. It's not anywhere near Shyamalan's best work, but it's certainly better than "Lady in the Water," and perhaps more satisfying than "The Village," which fell apart in the final minutes not because of the twist, but because of how the twist was presented.

• "I try to see what's on the screen, not what's gone before, and the movie I saw was truly, mysteriously awful. Unless, of course, it was meant to be a parody of such nature-lashing-out thrillers as "The Birds." But parodies are supposed to be funny, and the only laughs I heard were bad ones." -- Joe Morgenstern, Wall Street Journal

• "You feel like you're not watching the end of the world but the end of a career." -- Ty Burr, Boston Globe

• "It's a sorry enough spectacle to make admirers of 'The Sixth Sense' wonder if they didn't overrate that movie, and the director's whole oeuvre. Is Shyamalan a sham?" -- Richard Corliss, Time

• "This is the kind of movie that kills careers; it certain [sic] murdered my spirit for most of a day." -- Steve Prokopy, aka Capone, aintitcool.com

• "The scene in which (Zooey Deschanel) finds herself confronting a relentlessly ringing phone may be the single worst thing that anyone has ever done on screen." -- Peter Sobczynski, efilmcritic.com

• "What it turns out to be is a cinematic disaster of 'MST3K' proportions we haven’t seen from the likes of a major studio since, maybe ever." -- Erik Childress, efilmcritic.com

Read the full article here: http://blogs.dailyherald.com/node/182

I don't listen to critics most of the time as I like to judge things for myself. I typically don't watch movie trailers (I don't watch "broadcast" TV) as I like to be surprised by what I am about to watch.
But I think even I could do better than this movie.
I need to start writing. I have some good ideas.
daring
I have not seen the Happening or any of his movies since Unbreakable so I cannot comment on them. What I have been aware of is the downhill spiral of filmmakers in Hollyweird that make a great movie or two, then go in the pooper. It is like they make a great film (which is commendable) then they just make whatever junk floats across their desk. It seems like they lose the passion that made them a great filmmaker.

I don't understand the trend; it's like you can make even one great movie and that gives you a ticket into the Director's Free Pass Heaven, so no matter how bad the movies you make after that first hit you still keep getting to make movies.

I don't need to name names because there are some obvious examples out there. As an aspiring filmmaker myself I share the feeling that I can do better than many of the movies that I see on a regular basis. I just hope that I get the chance to put my stories on the big screen someday and that I do not ever lose the passion that makes great movies happen.
samuraijack
The problem is that they lose "The Hunger" for that goal. You see it with rock bands. It always presents in their second album. First albums are easy cause the band is hungry and they have a goal to reach. Second albums are hard because fame will test you in ways you didnt realize. Without your hunger are you really a good performer?

Once you hit the top, there is nowhere left to go and all you can do is look around and go "This is it?"
IF the top was your goal.

If you are a great storyteller/performer who just loves what they do, then you usually go "Cool, Lets do it again!"

M Knights career was over when he did the American Express card advertisement.
insertname
QUOTE (samuraijack @ Jun 24 2008, 06:49 AM) *
The problem is that they lose "The Hunger" for that goal. You see it with rock bands. It always presents in their second album. First albums are easy cause the band is hungry and they have a goal to reach. Second albums are hard because fame will test you in ways you didnt realize. Without your hunger are you really a good performer?

Once you hit the top, there is nowhere left to go and all you can do is look around and go "This is it?"
IF the top was your goal.

If you are a great storyteller/performer who just loves what they do, then you usually go "Cool, Lets do it again!"

M Knights career was over when he did the American Express card advertisement.


They loose that rawness, the " here we are , and if you don't like it then f**** off" eventually they start wearing makeup suing 15 year olds for millions, because nothing else matters...

jaded? sinicle? meeeeeeh coouuuld be; doc.

I'm interested to see what hes going to do with "Avatar"


The_Duchess
Personally, I liked The Happening. Wasn't too crazy about Lady in the Water, but at least it wasn't a story we've all heard a hundred times before. Mostly, I think I can't stand Paul Giamatti.

Shyamalan himself said The Happening was just supposed to be "a fun, B movie". I'll give it that and then some. The story was interesting, the characters were at least decent. I read a review that laughed at Betty Buckley's casting, which I completely disagree with. That old woman scared the hell out of me. I'm always impressed with a film that can get you to fear the most seemingly innocent things. This is what Hitchcock was after with The Birds but it just didn't come together. Yeah, film-lover heresy, but I've always thought that movie was overrated.

Coming from a very visually communicative background, M. Night does stunning work. Seeing the previews with the people falling from the skyscraper... well done. Then there is a scene, just a tiny cut, where Zooey Descehenel's character's coat is whipping in the wind. That's it, but it's beautiful.

So what that he used to do twists? So people saw the twist coming in The Village? I did too but it's still a VERY good film. Bigger themes at work. What are we willing to do to stay safe? Even if we set all the perimeters, can we ever really be safe? What lies will we tell our children in "their best intererest"? And as you mature, how do you react when you find you've been lied to? For me the most compelling issue was how far would you go to save the life of one you love? Yeah, very much been hashed over in every media out there, but Evie's dedication... Jeez, it's all done so well.

So it's highly unlikely Shyamalan will ever do another film that takes people in as much as The Sixth Sense. So what? There are geniuses and there are very gifted people who get a stroke of brilliance once or twice in a lifetime. I'm not sayin that either is the case here, but I do sympathize with someone who makes a living doing creative work not being able to summon lightning everytime. He's still head and shoulders above a lot of directors in Hollywood.
hoagtech
Oh man it wasn't very good, but I thought Paul Giamatti was the only thing holding it above water. Even if you cant relate to his personality or looks, I thibk he;'s a great compulsive, neurotic actor, sorta like george in seinfeld. (not a big fan of sideways thoguh)


QUOTE (The_Duchess @ Jun 24 2008, 08:04 AM) *
I think I can't stand Paul Giamatti.

lonewolfmichigan
Anyone who promotes the HOAX called man-made 'global warming' or 'climate change' is a shama lama ding dong in my humble opinion.That said,'Signs' is one of my favorite films.As soon as the corn gets tall this Summer,we're gonna go out back at night and watch it outside right next to the huge corn field with my diy projector and big screen.We all will get a little spooked I'm sure.Can't wait ohnoes.gif
The_Duchess
QUOTE (hoagtech @ Jun 24 2008, 10:53 AM) *
Oh man it wasn't very good, but I thought Paul Giamatti was the only thing holding it above water. Even if you cant relate to his personality or looks, I thibk he;'s a great compulsive, neurotic actor, sorta like george in seinfeld. (not a big fan of sideways thoguh)

I liked him well enough in Cinderella Man, but alot of other things are "meh" or just annoying. I guess I'm not a big fan of Jason Alexander either, and probably for the reasons you mentioned. Personally, my favorite man in show biz in Conan O'Brien, but a lot of people I know just think he's odd.

That's the great thing about the world, though, lots of options for what one likes or dislikes. It's cool that people here are respectful of others' opinions. I was wondering if going against the grain, so to speak, would meet with some derision, but apparently not. wink.gif
jonjandran
I watched "The Happening" last night.

What a snoozer. It didn't even have a single scary moment.

Afterwards all I could think is "What a waste of my time". rolleyes.gif

Not a good movie at all.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.