Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Capacitor Fan Backup?
Lumenlab > Audio Video Sciences > Advanced Projector Builder > DIY Electronics Projects
jdmlight
I am looking for a way to keep my fan running for a few minutes after I unplug it. I intended for my PSOne PJ to be fairly portable, so having to keep it plugged in for a bit after use is a drag. Also, I don't want to damage my PJ if the power goes out. I could use some form of battery backup, but I didn't think that batteries charged quickly enough. This is why I think that capacitors would work great. The only issue would be if the capacitors needed were high micro-farad values because this would make them large and expensive.

I will be running this fan, (120 mA, 1.44 W) at 7.5 volts. (yes I know that it says 8-14v, but it will run at 7.5v because my current fan runs at this voltage, having the same voltage rating on its package) My current fan is rather loud, thus is the reason why I will be replacing it with a SilenX fan, when it comes in. There must be an easy(ish) formula to calculate the drain of a capacitor with a certain current draw. (I might have just forgotten it since my last electronics class)

Please correct me if this isn't possible (or practical). If it isn't, could you offer another solution to this problem?
Natural Newbie
Well if the fan had a constant resistance (or current draw) it would be simple. But since the fans current draw will be a function of the voltage, which will decrease with time after the power source is removed, it would be a differential equation (not fun).

I would say but the biggest capacitor(s) you are willing to spend the money on, and see how long it lasts and go from there.
jdmlight
QUOTE (Natural Newbie @ Mar 19 2007, 07:20 PM) *
Well if the fan had a constant resistance (or current draw) it would be simple. But since the fans current draw will be a function of the voltage, which will decrease with time after the power source is removed, it would be a differential equation (not fun).

I could use a step-up voltage regulator (switching, I think it's called) to keep the voltage, and thus the current, the same. And no, I haven't gotten to DiffEQ yet. That's college. I'm in high school.

QUOTE (Natural Newbie @ Mar 19 2007, 07:20 PM) *
I would say buy the biggest capacitor(s) you are willing to spend the money on, and see how long it lasts and go from there.

Not a bad suggestion either. I will have to try that tomorrow with some capacitors I have sitting around.
Natural Newbie
Sounds like a plan.

Remember if you have multiple capacitors wire them in paralell with the battery and fan, and if you have multiple capacitors wire them all in paralell.

If you have an array of capacitors you could make a graph of Farads vs Fan run time, and extropolate the curve to see how many Farads it would take for a desired fan run time.
arizonavideo
Capacitors are a bad idea. Even a large bank will only run a fan for 5 seconds or so unless you buy $100 worth. If you only want around 5 seconds then it might be OK.

Charging caps is a little tricky too. A transformer is fine but a solid state PS will have to deal with a “short” at start up.

I'm open for a debate on whether it is better to let a lamp cool slowly or fast with a fan.

When you turn out the lamp it stops making heat too.
Durachko
Use a thermal switch. You owe me two cents. tongue.gif
QUOTE (arizonavideo @ Mar 20 2007, 01:55 AM) *
I'm open for a debate on whether it is better to let a lamp cool slowly or fast with a fan.
What do you see as the downside(s) of active cooling after powering down? You thinking thermal stress or something else?
jdmlight
QUOTE (Durachko @ Mar 20 2007, 07:10 AM) *
Use a thermal switch.

I would, except you didn't read the part about "keep my fan running after I unplug it." rolleyes.gif

QUOTE
A 1-farad capacitor can hold 1 amp-second of electrons at 1 volt.

To get some perspective on how big a farad is, think about this:

A typical alkaline AA battery holds about 2.8 amp-hours.
That means that a AA battery can produce 2.8 amps for an hour at 1.5 volts (about 4.2 watt-hours -- a AA battery can light a 4-watt bulb for a little more than an hour).
Let's call it 1 volt to make the math easier. To store one AA battery's energy in a capacitor, you would need 3,600 * 2.8 = 10,080 farads to hold it, because an amp-hour is 3,600 amp-seconds.
If it takes something the size of a can of tuna to hold a farad, then 10,080 farads is going to take up a LOT more space than a single AA battery! Obviously, it is impractical to use capacitors to store any significant amount of power unless you do it at a high voltage.

edit: This is from HowStuffWorks.com
Now, that means that I could get about 5 seconds of power from a capacitor the size of a tuna can, if the fan only took one volt. ohmy.gif

This confirms what arizonavideo said (I will still try it tonight, just because I can tongue.gif). Is there another way to accomplish the same idea? How about those 15-minute charge batteries? The only issue that I could see with those is that they might overheat in my PJ case, but I could always put them near my lens (away from the hot bulbs). These should work, right?
Durachko
QUOTE (jdmlight @ Mar 20 2007, 06:30 PM) *
I would, except you didn't read the part about "keep my fan running after I unplug it." rolleyes.gif
Well, I did read it but chose to ignore it. smile.gif These aren't really plug&play units IMHO and I just can't see the sense in going for a capacitive storage device to accomplish your goal. What's the big deal in leaving something plugged in for 5 minutes to achieve cooling? But that's simply my opinion.

That said I'd strongly lean towards either dry cells or rechargeables. Your "on" time and the low self-discharge rate of NiCd cells will allow for on-board charging during use. You'd still need the thermal switch anyway to shut 'em off.

Stay away from NiMH due to them being less robust chargewise, self-dischargewise, and heat tolerantwise than NiCd cells. Again, my opinions. wink.gif

Good luck!
arizonavideo
Simple.

Click to view attachment
JAY777
To charge the cap bank just use a 1 watt 200 ohm resistor to ease the pull on the power supply.
Big caps are everywhere just take old broken things apart and try them.
!!!!!!!!!!!!! CAPS HOLD A CHARGE FOR A VERY LONG TIME SO BE CAREFUL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
jdmlight
QUOTE (JAY777 @ Mar 21 2007, 12:11 PM) *
Big caps are everywhere

Yes, that would be the problem, the "big" part - there's not much room in my case (remember I made it to be portable).
jdmlight
QUOTE (Durachko @ Mar 21 2007, 07:49 AM) *
That said I'd strongly lean towards either dry cells or rechargeables. Your "on" time and the low self-discharge rate of NiCd cells will allow for on-board charging during use.
...
Stay away from NiMH due to them being less robust chargewise, self-dischargewise, and heat tolerantwise than NiCd cells.

I agree (after some quick research on the benefits and drawbacks of NICD and NIMH batteries) that NICD batteries are better suited for my application. Are there any 15-minute NICD battery chargers? They don't have to be made for AA's; they could be made for, say, a cordless drill or RC car.
tgreenwood
In the plog for your PSOne projector you say that the outlet air from your fan is 96.3 degrees fahrenheit.
Is this fan backup for a different projector? If its for the PSOne projector using the fluorescent bulbs I don't think that you need to keep the fans running after the lamps are turned off. It's cool enough already.

Tgreenwood
jdmlight
QUOTE (tgreenwood @ Mar 21 2007, 06:52 PM) *
In the plog for your PSOne projector you say that the outlet air from your fan is 96.3 degrees fahrenheit.
Is this fan backup for a different projector? If its for the PSOne projector using the fluorescent bulbs I don't think that you need to keep the fans running after the lamps are turned off. It's cool enough already.

Oh. Well, in that case, never mind. It still would be nice for others who may be reading this to finish the concept though.
tgreenwood
It is an interesting concept and I'm sorry if I burst your bubble. Didn't mean to.

Tgreenwood
jdmlight
QUOTE (tgreenwood @ Mar 21 2007, 10:38 PM) *
It is an interesting concept and I'm sorry if I burst your bubble. Didn't mean to.

That's OK, it just makes my projector lighter without batteries and a charger. smile.gif I could still test it, but I won't spend much money or time on it. If someone else is interested in the concept, by all means give it a try.

edit: I tried the capacitors, and it's definitely not worth it. If you need your fan to stay on after your projector's unplugged, use one of the 9-volt rechargeable batteries illustrated above.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.